Middle and Pinky: Revlon - Carbonite
Pointer and Ring: L'Oreal - Valiant
Carbonite looks a little rougher and leans more gold. At least to my eye.
Ignore my messy valiant fingers. I remembered when I was using it that this is the polish I use on my dog once and awhile, so I was pulling hairs out of the brush. Gross, I know! Sorry!
If I had to get rid of one: No way! Love them both!