Battle of the Purples!

 Pointer and Ring: Kleancolor - "Fairy Lover"

Middle and Pinky: Spa Ritual - "Health, Wealth and Happiness"

 Fairy Lover (I swear I bought it just because of the name!) is a thick, rich blue-toned purple.
HW&H is a little on the thin side, but this is three coats and it builds to an amazingly gorgeous almost multi-hued shimmer. It shift purple-blue very prettily.

Best of both worlds. One layer of HW&H over Fairy Lover. Perfection!

Verdict: Not alike!

If I had to get rid of one: No, way, they're both awesome!