I can't remember if the City Color ever had a name. I bought it...this year I think? It was a cheapie Rite-Aid polish. It's actually quite pretty. The brush is thin and kind of annoying, but nothing too awful. Both of these are over a layer of Wet-n-Wild "I need a refreshmint" see it hiding out back there?
Index and Ring: City Color
Middle and Pinky: CQ Gem Green
Gem Green has been featured on here before but it is so lovely, it deserves more attention!
Look at that shimmery goodness!
Verdict: NOT dupes
If I had to get rid of one: Nope, gotta keep them both!